The Crow: 9 Differences Between The Comics And The Movie

With the 2024 reboot starring Bill Skarsgard arriving to mixed reviews, interest in the cult favorite The Crow has been steadily rising. While there are many fans of the original starring the late Brandon Lee, it’s not as widely known that the 1994 movie is actually based on the 1989 comic book series The Crow. With a killer soundtrack and the spot-on casting of Lee in the titular role, the film enjoys a steady fan base that has only grown since its release in the early nineties.

Good essay

Like all movie adaptations of comic books and graphic novels, there are a number of differences between the on-page and on-screen version of The Crow. The Crow comics were created by James O’Barr, and was a veritable hit, being translated into almost a dozen languages so far. The dark and macabre tone of the source material that readers know and love stays intact for the film version, something that is rarely accomplished in book-to-screen adaptions. However, while the 1994 The Crow movie kept the general feel of the comic books, there were also several notable changes made to the narrative and Eric Draven, the titular gothic antihero.

You are watching: The Crow: 9 Differences Between The Comics And The Movie

Related 8 The Crow Differences Between Bill Skarsgård & Brandon Lee’s Appearance

As Bill Skarsgård takes up the mantle of playing The Crow, his styling and costume show some big changes from the original Brandon Lee version.

Albrecht In The Crow Movie Is A Composite Character

A Blend of Two Comic Figures with a Significant Change

One of the key characters in 1994’s The Crow is Sergeant Albrecht, played by Ernie Hudson. Albrecht is Eric Draven’s closest ally once he becomes the Crow, and also tried his hardest to save Draven’s girlfriend, Shelly, before she died. This included remaining with her for over 24 hours while she suffered through her pain, a fact that made Albrecht an incredibly endearing character in his own right.

Outside the pawn shop, Draven is confronted by a police officer named Albrecht. His name is spelled ‘Albrect’ in the comic and ‘Albrecht’ in the movie credits.

Given Albrecht’s significane in 1994’s The Crow, it is somewhat surprising to learn that the character didn’t exist in the comic books. Or, to be more accuract, that he’s a combination of two characters from James O’Barr’s version of the story. Albrecht is a mixture of the comics’ characters of a nervous rookie cop who encounters the Crow, and Captain Hook, who was the officer that stayed by Eric’s bedside in the hospital after the murder.

Differences in how Eric and Albrecht met Comics vs. Film
In the comic	The scene takes place inside Gideon’s store.
	This occurs just before Eric blows it up.
	Albrect says “Freeze!”
In the movie	The scene takes place outside, after the shop has already been destroyed.
	Albrecht says “Don’t move!”
	Draven replies, “I thought the police always said ‘Freeze!'”

Film Version Sarah Takes The Place Of The Crow Comic’s Sherry

A Move to Avoid Confusion

See more : Is Barbara Handler Still Alive? Who is Barbara Handler? Barbara Handler Age, Net Worth and more

Another character who changes in The Crow movie (though not as significantly as Albrecht) is that of Sarah, who was originally called Sherry in the comic. The change from the book’s name of Sherry to the film’s name of Sarah was most likely done in a way to reduce the repetition of the similar-sounding names of Shelly and Sherry, but otherwise the characters are extremely similar. In both versions, the character is a little girl who befriends Eric as the Crow while he enacts his vengeance.

Also, in both film and book versions of The Crow, she is the daughter of the character Funboy’s girlfriend. Funboy remains a gang member that plays a part in Shelly’s murder in both versions of The Crow. Of all the changes the 1994 movie made to The Crow comic, this is one of the most sensible, as it likely would have confused viewers hearing two names that are so similar (which isn’t as much of an issue for readers, where the spelling makes it obvious who’s being referred to).

Top Dollar Was Elevated To Be A Main Antagonist In The Crow Movie

From Gang Member to Main Villain

Michael Wincott provided the 1994 The Crow movie with a chilling and incredibly gripping antagonist, as his character Top Dollar added a great deal of tension to Eric Draven’s story of posthumous vengeance. However, in The Crow comic book, Top Dollar isn’t the central villain that Wincott portrayed on-screen. The literary version of Top Dollar is a gang member who has his own crew of drug pushers. But, the character dies in a way that is similar to the rest of the thugs who are responsible for the death of Shelly and Eric.

Elevating Top Dollar was one of the best changes made in The Crow movie. In the 1994 film, Top Dollar is the central antagonist rather than just another one of the murderous thugs. The theatrical version of Top Dollar is portrayed as an eccentric kingpin who runs the city. As Top Dollar is the main villain in the film, he gets his own climactic showdown with the Crow, another big departure from the book. This change worked incredibly well for the movie, as it gave the story of The Crow a cohesive narrative more befitting of the feature-film format.

Related Every Actor Who Has Played The Crow

The Crow franchise has had different actors playing the title character in movies and TV shows, and not all of them have played Eric Draven.

The Motives Behind The Murder Of Eric Draven Differ

Top Dollar’s Indirect Role In Shelly’s Death In The Crow

In The Crow movie, Top Dollar was the one who sent T-Bird and the crew to be where Shelly was on the night of her murder, but he was not there himself, making him responsible for Shelly’s death but not directly. Shelly had been campaigning for tenant rights in a building that Top Dollar owned, so the gang was sent to rough up the tenants and scare them.

In the comic version of The Crow, there’s no underlying motive behind Eric and Shelly’s deaths. Instead, Eric and Shelly are killed in an act of wanton and almost-random violence, and Eric goes on his revenge rampage, taking out each of the gang members who murdered him and his girlfriend. One wild detail of The Crow is that Eric and Shelly’s murder in the comics is based on a real crime the author read about when writing, which entailed a couple being robbed for their engagement ring and being needlessly killed in the process.

Movie Crow Experiences More Difficulties Than Book Crow

Eric’s Struggles In The Film Adaptation of The Crow Help Humanize His Character

One of the best aspects of The Crow movie are that Eric’s journey of revenge isn’t an easy one. He’s beset by many obstacles, and his newfound powers don’t give him a huge advantage over his targets. This isn’t the case in The Crow comics, however. In the book, Eric, now the Crow, manages to kill off every member of the villainous gang without any interference, setbacks, or difficulties.

The only things that interrupt his revenge killings are his bouts of depression and grief over the loss of Shelly, episodes of self-harm, and reminiscing on better memories of the past. This is a stark contrast to the 1994 movie, which has many moments when Eric struggles to get his revenge. For example, when Eric tries to kill the character Tin Tin, he gets severely beaten up before eventually killing him, and there is a car chase before the Crow is able to kill T-Bird.

Film Eric Goes On The Run From The Cops

The Two Versions Of The Crow Different Depictions Of Grief And Revenge

As the film version of Top Dollar is more like a kingpin who runs the city, Eric Draven in 1994’s The Crow faces more consequences for his vigilante ways than his comic-book counterpart. While the comic-book Crow is able to kill off multiple gang members without consequence, in the movie, the law is far from happy when Eric kills many of Top Dollar’s men.

As a result, in the film, Eric has to be on the run from the cops for a while until he eventually gets Albrecht’s help to escape. This occurrence is nonexistent in the book and Eric never has to evade the police in The Crow comics. Eric’s hiding from the cops adds to the suspense and helps make The Crow one of the best horror movies inspired by a comic book series.

Sarah Is Given History With Pre-Crow Eric And Shelly In The Film

It Sets Up Different Challenges And Goals For Eric’s Revenge Than The Crow Comics

In both versions of The Crow, Sarah/Sherry befriends The Crow as he attempts to accomplish his vendetta. However, in the 1994 movie, Sarah had actually known Eric and Shelly before Eric became the Crow and Shelly died. Sarah and Shelly were close, as Shelly acted as a maternal figure to the neglected Sarah, whose real mother was addicted to drugs and had a toxic relationship with Funboy.

In the film, the Crow magically draws out the drugs in Sarah’s mom’s veins, making her realize that she needs to be a better parent whereas, in the book, there is only a note left for the cops to take care of Sarah/Sherry. This is one difference between The Crow movie and comic-books that may be seen as divisive, as some have commented that it’s a little too “feel good” to fit the tone of the story.

See more : What We Do in the Shadows Season 5 Episode 8 Release Date and Time, Countdown, When Is It Coming Out?

Related The Crow: 20 Best Quotes From The Film

The Crow has amassed a cult following over the years since its release, and here are 20 quotes from the film that’ll stick with viewers forever.

The Crow Comics And Movie Differ In Their Focus

Book’s Destructive Grief vs. Film’s Constructive Journey

It’s not only various characters and events that were changed from The Crow comic books for the 1994 film. The two versions also have different thematic focuses, using the same rough story to explore different aspects of the human experience. The Crow comic book trains its eye more on the topics of what it means to love and lose and the pain and anger that follow. The comics still feature a vengeance-based rampage, but the focus is not on revenge but rather on grief.

The character of the Crow in James O’Barr’s comics is meant to act as a personification of grief, showing grief as a destructive force that must wreak its havoc until it has run its course.

The character of the Crow in James O’Barr’s comics is meant to act as a personification of grief, showing grief as a destructive force that must wreak its havoc until it has run its course. On the other hand, the 1994 movie is more about the Crow’s journey and it uses grief as a constructive force that motivates the Crow to finish what he started in order for him to be able to return to his own grave in peace. The movie’s comments on grief help make the original The Crow the best of the franchise.

The Endings Of The Crow Movie And Comics Differ

The Crow’s Final Showdown And Peaceful Rest

One of the biggest differences between the on-screen and on-page versions of The Crow is how the stories conclude. In the 1994 movie version of The Crow, Top Dollar and his girlfriend Myca deduce that the crow is Eric’s guide, and that by killing the crow they will be killing Eric, who will no longer be immortal. Eric returns to his grave when he thinks his revenge is finished. However, Sarah is kidnapped by one of Top Dollar’s goons and Eric leaves his grave to rescue her.

When face to face with Top Dollar and Myca, she shoots the crow guide, leaving Eric wounded, and tries to take the crow’s power for herself. Top Dollar admits his part in Shelly and Eric’s deaths. As a result, Eric gives Top Dollar the thirty hours of pain he absorbed from Albrecht which, overloads Top Dollar and sends him to his death. Eric returns to his grave and rests in peace with Shelly. In The Crow comic book, the ending is much simpler. The story simply concludes once Eric has killed all the gang members and then the book ends with Eric in his grave with Shelly.

The Crow 1

Your Rating

5 stars4.5 stars4 stars3.5 stars3 star2.5 stars2 stars1.5 stars1 stars0.5 star Rate Now Submit Rate Now Edit Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

RActionDramaSupernatural Where to Watch

stream
rent
buy

Not available

*Availability in US

Based on the comic series, The Crow is a supernatural-action film that follows a murdered musician who returns from the dead for vengeance. Eric Draven and his fiancee are murdered during a violent home invasion – but supernatural forces have other plans for Draven. Resurrected by the power of a mysterious crow, the now superpowered Draven takes on the mantle of “The Crow” and seeks revenge against the entire gang that killed him and his wife.

Director Alex Proyas Release Date May 13, 1994 Studio(s) Dimension Films Distributor(s) Miramax Films Writers David J. Schow , John Shirley Cast Brandon Lee , Ernie Hudson , Michael Wincott , Rochelle Davis , Bai Ling , Sofia Shinas , Anna Levine , David Patrick Kelly Runtime 102 Minutes Franchise(s) The Crow Sequel(s) The Crow: City of Angels , The Crow: Salvation , The Crow: Wicked Prayer Budget $23 Million Expand

Source: https://truongnguyenbinhkhiem.edu.vn
Category: Entertainment