10 Horror Movies That Should Have Been Nominated For Best Picture At The Oscars

Horror
movies have been captivating audiences since the film industry’s early days. German Expressionist pictures like F. W. Murnau’s 1922 silent Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror were among the first films to introduce the archetypes of on-screen terror. Considering the movie was remade over a century later with Robert Eggers’ Nosferatu, it’s clear that the adoration for the genre has persisted over time. However, despite its popularity among moviegoers, horror has an unusual relationship with industry critics.

It’s rare for the average scary film to have a high Rotten Tomatoes score, let alone bring home an Oscar. The first horror movie to be put up for Best Picture was The Exorcist in 1973. In total, only seven have been nominated for the top category, with The Silence of the Lambs being the sole winner. The Oscar’s 2025 Best Picture nominees brought this number to seven after Coralie Fargeat’s The Substance was recently added to the roster. Unfortunately, the Academy has missed its mark on many deserving titles.

10

The Omen (1976)

Directed By Richard Donner

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

The Omen

R

Horror

7/10

Release Date

June 25, 1976

Runtime

111 minutes

Cast

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Lee Remick

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Gregory Peck

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

It’s easy to gauge a movie’s influence when it inspires a four-installment franchise and a remake. Richard Donner’s The Omen effectively established the demonic child trope that is now all too familiar in horror. There’s something so unsettling about pure evil under the guise of an innocent face. The original version was the first try at the concept, and it hasn’t been matched since. This film introduced Damien (Harvey Spencer Stephens), an adopted evil toddler set on wreaking havoc on the world around him.

The Silence of the Lambs and The Substance characters with an Oscar trophy

Related

All 7 Horror Movies Nominated For Best Picture At The Oscars

Only seven movies in the history of the horror genre have been nominated for the Best Picture award at the Oscars, creating a small, elite club.

Posts

After its 1976 release, The Omen was nominated for two Academy Awards, Best Song and Best Score, for which Jerry Goldsmith won the latter. Given how strong the atmosphere and performances are, it seems crazy that the movie didn’t receive a Best Picture nomination. The recent 2024 prequel dubbed The First Omen​​​​​​ is also surprisingly strong and will hopefully give more recognition to the story moving forward.

9

Rosemary’s Baby (1968)

Directed By Roman Polanski

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Rosemary’s Baby

R

Horror

Drama

ScreenRant logo

8/10

8/10

Release Date

June 12, 1968

Runtime

137 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Ralph Bellamy

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Mia Farrow

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Rosemary’s Baby inspired an entire generation to stop hanging out with their neighbors. It’s as classic of a horror film as they come, and one of the most recognizable titles of the genre. Considering its critical acclaim, it seems like a Best Picture nomination would be an expectation, if not a guarantee. Unfortunately, the movie failed to strike gold at the 41st Academy Awards. Rosemary’s Baby was nominated for two awards in total, with the only winner being Mia Farrow for Best Supporting Actress.

However, it isn’t surprising that the film came up short. No other horror movie had been nominated for the award previously, and nobody expected anything to change. Nevertheless, Rosemary’s Baby elevated the genre to new heights that deserve recognition. The unique paranoia-driven dynamic of the plot is relatable to broader audiences, which makes the premise all the more terrifying. It was recently given a prequel with Natalie Erka James’ Apartment 7A​​​​, but the reviews have been less than stellar.

8

Hereditary (2018)

Directed By Ari Aster

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Hereditary

R

Horror

Documentary

Mystery

Thriller

ScreenRant logo

7/10

12

7.3/10

Release Date

June 8, 2018

Runtime

2h 7m

Cast

  • Headshot Of Toni Collette

    Toni Collette

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Milly Shapiro

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

In 2018, Ari Aster pulled off an incredibly difficult feat: a critically acclaimed modern horror film. Although movies like Get Out and The Witch demonstrate that it’s still possible for these directors to strike gold, it’s a rare occurrence. Hereditary excels in all measures of quality. It’s a refreshingly original story that takes the genre in a new direction while incorporating an approach to terror that doesn’t leave anyone safe.

While it is surely upsetting that Hereditary was never nominated for Best Picture, the fact that Toni Collette didn’t win or was even nominated for Best Actress is regarded as one of the biggest Oscar snubs in modern history. There have been few performances in recent years that hold a candle to her work as the seemingly ordinary mother slowly transforms into a nightmarish demon that terrorizes the family. Although the competition at the 90th Academy Awards was strong, Hereditary should still have been a contender. It’s easily one of the best A24 movies and a marvel of modern horror.

7

The Thing (1982)

Directed By John Carpenter

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

The Thing

R

Horror

Sci-Fi

Mystery

ScreenRant logo

10/10

11

9.5/10

Release Date

June 25, 1982

Runtime

109 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    T.K. Carter

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    David Clennon

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

It’s funny how critical reception tends to change in retrospect; there are plenty of poorly received movies that became classics. Sometimes, individuals of the period don’t recognize greatness immediately. In the case of John Carptenter’s The Thing, hindsight was 20-20. Despite being regarded as one of the greatest sci-fi movies ever made, the critics and audiences of 1982 didn’t hold the same opinion. It wasn’t just that people thought the film was bad, they actively piled on the negativity.

Childs from The Thing with One of Its Many Forms

Related

The Thing Answered Its Biggest Cliffhanger Over 30 Years Ago Without You Noticing

A long-forgotten series of comics from Dark Horse answered the biggest question from John Carpenter’s The Thing. However, should it have an answer?

Posts

The Thing‘s score was nominated for a Razzie Award, meaning that it was collectively recognized for its lack of quality. The same score is now held on a pedestal for its eerie innovation. This movie is second to none in its ability to create a chilling atmosphere. A monster that can assume the form of its victim is terrifying enough, but when it’s framed in an isolated setting, the result is hard to watch. For being hailed as one of the genre’s greats, The Thing deserved so much more.

6

The Witch (2016)

Directed By Robert Eggers

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

The Witch

R

Horror

ScreenRant logo

7/10

15

9.3/10

Release Date

February 19, 2016

Runtime

92minutes

Cast

  • Headshot Of Kate Dickie In The UK film premiere of 'Mrs. Lowry & Son'

    Kate Dickie

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Wahab Chaudhry

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Robert Eggers has continued his run as one of the most exciting filmmakers of the modern generation. His full-length feature resume reflects a career of quality over quantity, consisting of The Lighthouse, The Northman, Nosferatu, and most importantly, The Witch. It was his first attempt at a commercial horror movie, but the result made it seem like a product of a seasoned director. Eggers specializes in his exploration of folklore, and The Witch is no exception.

It’s an anxiety-producing, slow-burn period piece about a child abduction that never fails to be unsettling. Unfortunately, the movie was also nowhere to be seen at the Academy Awards. In all fairness, The Witch isn’t a traditional Best Picture nominee. Even if it weren’t a horror film, the off-beat dynamic of the plot makes the audience appeal niche. That said, the overall quality speaks for itself, and worse alternatives were nominated in its stead. After the success of Nosferatu, Robert Eggers’ next horror movie will undoubtedly be something special.

5

Alien (1979)

Directed By Ridley Scott

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Official theatrical poster for Alien (1979)

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Alien

R

Sci-Fi

Horror

ScreenRant logo

10/10

20

9.5/10

Release Date

June 22, 1979

Runtime

117 Minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Sigourney Weaver In The James Cameron And Jon Landau Handprints And Footprints Ceremony.

    Sigourney Weaver

    Ripley

  • Headshot Of Tom Skerritt

    Tom Skerritt

    Dallas

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Although it started as a singular spaceship horror flick, Alien has slowly carved out a fully fledged cinematic universe since its 1979 release. It’s also considered one of the best sci-fi movies of all time, and there isn’t much of a debate. Ridley Scott managed to establish a wide array of new cinematic milestones while demonstrating the potential that the space horror genre had to offer. However, creating a film in a sci-fi world doesn’t help its chances with the Academy, and adding an element of horror makes the odds even weaker.

The original title for Alien was Star Beast​​​​​.

Alien was nominated for two awards at the 52nd Oscars ceremony, winning Best Visual Effects but coming up short for Best Art Direction. Scott’s employment of groundbreaking practical effects brought the Xenomorphs to life in a way that nobody could’ve expected. Better yet, they were incorporated into a gritty, realistic, and terrifying plot with tension that hasn’t been replicated since. It’s a film that outlasted the competition for the year and was snubbed of proper recognition.

4

The Others (2001)

Directed By Alejandro Amenábar

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

the others poster

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

The Others

PG-13

Mystery

Thriller

Horror

9.2/10

Release Date

August 10, 2001

Runtime

104 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Nicole Kidman In The Los Angeles Premiere Of Netflix's 'A Family Affair'

    Nicole Kidman

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    James Bentley

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Despite its significant box office success, Alejandro Amenábar’s The Others remains relatively unknown in the vein of go-to horror films. Armed with a modest budget of $17 million, the movie was a heavy-hitter in theaters, bringing in a worldwide gross of $210 million. Unsurprisingly, the reception was very positive among audiences and critics alike. The Others uses the small space it’s given and creates a memorable piece of horror.

The plot follows Grace Stewart (Nicole Kidman), a mother living with photosensitive children in a dark estate home that quickly turns into a sinister abode. Considering the fierce competition with the beginning of The Lord of the Rings, it ​​​​​​wasn’t a strong enough project to bring home the title. With that being said, Amenábar’s direction and Kidman’s performance were strong enough to merit a nomination. The Others’ ending also offers a unique twist that blows the lid off the apparent circumstances.

3

Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992)

Directed By Francis Ford Coppola

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

n39glc4gkbecbwdenes8zbodim8.jpg

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Bram Stoker’s Dracula

R

Horror

Romance

1/10

Release Date

November 13, 1992

Runtime

127 Minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Gary Oldman In The 77th Cannes Film Festival

    Gary Oldman

    Dracula

  • Headshot Of Winona Ryder In The Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards

    Winona Ryder

    Mina Murray / Elisabeta

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Often hailed as one of the greatest directors of all time, Francis Ford Coppola is no stranger to memorable films. From The Godfather to Apocalypse Now, he’s been massively influential in the evolution of Hollywood. However, Bram Stoker’s Dracula is often outshined by the director’s magnum opus, and although the film arrived in the latter part of his career, it’s a criminally underrated addition to the horror genre.

Coppola’s imagination of the Dracula tale benefited from its adherence to the source material. Bram Stoker’s original 1897 novel is horrifying on its own, and Coppola used this to his advantage. Gary Oldman’s masterful portrayal of the cunning Count Dracula only improved the product further. Luckily, the Academy members of the time recognized aspects of its quality. The film brought home awards for Best Costume Design, Best Effects, and Best Makeup, but fell short of a Best Picture nomination.

2

The Shining (1980)

Directed By Stanley Kubrick

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

The Shining

R

Horror

Drama

ScreenRant logo

10/10

33

8.5/10

Release Date

June 13, 1980

Runtime

146 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Danny Lloyd

  • Headshot Of Shelley Duvall

    Shelley Duvall

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

The Shining tends to surface quickly in conversations of the scariest movies of all time. From the mind of Stephen King and the directorial prowess of Stanley Kubrick, it’s a perfect storm of two creatives at work. One would expect such an iconic film to garner excellent critical reception from the second it hit theaters, but this wasn’t the case. When it came out in 1980, The Shining was considered a complete flop.

Custom image of Jack and Wendy in the Shining

Related

The Shining: The Wendy Theory, Explained

The Wendy Theory is a theory about Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining, a movie that has remained in pop culture, partially because of its many theories.

Posts

6

Audiences of the period weren’t comfortable with the slow-burn, atmospheric narrative that Kubrick is so famous for. It proved to work for 2001: A Space Odyssey, but critics felt like it was boring in a horror-themed environment. The psychological whirlpool was nothing more than a hindrance to the final action. Opposition to the movie was so high that Kubrick and Shelly Duvall were both put up for Worst Director and Worst Actress Razzies. As ridiculous as it sounds now, the Best Picture Nomination was off the table.

1

Misery (1990)

Directed By Rob Reiner

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Misery

R

Horror

Thriller

Drama

ScreenRant logo

10/10

10

8.9/10

Release Date

November 30, 1990

Runtime

107 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Richard Farnsworth

  • Headshot Of James Caan

    James Caan

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

If a movie is critically acclaimed, successful at the box office, and armed with the Best Actress winner in the leading role, how can it fail to even be considered for Best Picture? Misery arguably deserved the nomination more than any other film in the genre. Dances With Wolves won the 63rd Academy Awards, but the competition wasn’t strong enough to bar Misery from a mere nomination. Considering it’s Stephen King source material, the story was guaranteed to be great. However, the cast and crew went the extra mile.

Kathy Bates’s performance as Annie Wilkes is one of the best to ever hit the screens, a feat that earned her a Best Actress win. It’s easy to forget that Misery takes place in one spot for the majority of its runtime. Director Rob Reiner utilizes the horror of isolation and helplessness in a perspective that feels personal. It’s as if the audience is similarly confined to the cabin of solitude. Misery might not have been the obvious winner, but a Best Picture nomination only seems fair, if it weren’t horror.

Leave a Comment